Mango Mail vs MailAfiniti: Shared vs Per-Mailbox Storage
Mango Mail costs $18–$174/year for unlimited mailboxes, but storage and daily sending limits are shared across the account. MailAfiniti is $18/mailbox/year with 10 GB each. Here's which costs less for your team.
5.0 on Trustpilot, from every review so farBusiness Email Specialist, MailAfiniti
Quick Verdict
Mango Mail and MailAfiniti both start at $18 a year, but they measure different things. Mango gives you unlimited mailboxes and domains and caps the account: 5 GB of storage and 50 outgoing emails a day on Startup, shared by everyone. MailAfiniti charges per mailbox and gives each person their own 10 GB. For one person, or a large team that sends little, Mango is a good deal. For a small team that emails all day, per-mailbox pricing gives each person more room for a similar price.
How we compared
MailAfiniti is our product, so read this with that in mind. We compare published list prices (including renewal and billing-term catches), storage, DNS and SPF/DKIM/DMARC setup, migration, and support. Check current Mango Mail pricing on their site, since prices change.
TL;DR: Mango Mail's plans cost $18, $60 or $174 a year (standard rates) for unlimited mailboxes and domains. The limits sit on the whole account: Startup has 5 GB of storage and 50 outgoing emails a day, shared by everyone. MailAfiniti costs $18 per mailbox per year with 10 GB for each person. With equal storage per person, the two cost about the same up to ten people. The difference is whether your team can live inside one shared quota.
Unlimited mailboxes, shared limits
Mango Mail (mymangomail.com) has a simple pitch: pay for the data you use, not the number of mailboxes. Every plan includes unlimited addresses and unlimited domains, and Mango's FAQ confirms the only limit is the plan's total data. That's a good model if you run several small businesses or need lots of role addresses.
What you trade for it is a set of account-wide limits. On Mango's own plan details page, each plan has a cap on storage, incoming mail and outgoing mail per day, and that cap is shared by every mailbox on the account:
| Mango plan | Price (standard) | Storage | Outgoing / day | Incoming / day |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Startup | $18/year | 5 GB | 50 | 200 |
| Small Business | $60/year | 30 GB | 100 | 1,000 |
| Mini Tycoon | $174/year | 100 GB | 500 | 3,000 |
For one person, 50 emails a day is plenty. For a five-person sales team on Startup, it's ten emails each, per day, for the whole team.
MailAfiniti works the other way. You pay per mailbox, and each mailbox has its own storage: 10, 30 or 50 GB depending on plan. One person filling their inbox doesn't take space from anyone else.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | MailAfiniti | Mango Mail |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per mailbox | Per account (unlimited mailboxes) |
| Entry price | $2/mailbox/mo ($1.50 billed annually) | $18/year Startup (standard rate) |
| Storage | 10 / 30 / 50 GB per mailbox | 5 / 30 / 100 GB shared per account |
| Domains | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Aliases | Unlimited, free | Unlimited addresses |
| Custom domain | Every plan | Every plan |
| Migration | Free on Professional and Enterprise, done for you | Self-service SimpleTransfer (100 messages per transfer on Startup) |
| Human support | Every plan | Every plan |
| Works with Outlook / Apple Mail | IMAP / SMTP / POP3 | IMAP / SMTP / POP3 |
| Free trial | 14 days, no card | Free trial available |
Mango also offers fallback domains, and server-side filters on its paid plans. And unlimited mailboxes for $18 a year is a strong offer if your mailboxes are mostly quiet.
Pricing Breakdown
Mango Mail pricing in 2026
Mango lists three plans, priced per account:
- Startup: $1.50/month ($18 per year). 5 GB, 50 outgoing emails/day, no active filters.
- Small Business: $5/month ($60 per year). 30 GB, 100 outgoing emails/day, 100 active filters.
- Mini Tycoon: $14.50/month ($174 per year). 100 GB, 500 outgoing emails/day, 300 active filters.
(Standard rates from mymangomail.com/plan-details as of November 10, 2026. Mango's homepage currently advertises discounts of 50%, 30% and 10% off these plans. Check whether a discount applies to renewals before you compare multi-year costs.)
MailAfiniti Pricing
- Starter: $2/mailbox/month, or $1.50 billed annually ($18/year). 10 GB per mailbox.
- Professional: $3/mailbox/month, or $2.25 billed annually ($27/year). 30 GB per mailbox, free migration.
- Enterprise: $5/mailbox/month, or $3.75 billed annually ($45/year). 50 GB per mailbox.
What you actually pay, by team size
Yearly billing, Mango at standard rates. The Mango column shows the cheapest plan that fits the team, then what each person gets on it.
| Team size | MailAfiniti Starter | Mango cheapest plan | Per person on Mango |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 person | $18 (10 GB) | $18 Startup | 5 GB, 50 sends/day |
| 3 people | $54 (10 GB each) | $18 Startup | 1.7 GB, ~16 sends/day |
| 5 people | $90 (10 GB each) | $18 Startup | 1 GB, 10 sends/day |
| 10 people | $180 (10 GB each) | $60 Small Business | 3 GB, 10 sends/day |
| 20 people | $360 (10 GB each) | $174 Mini Tycoon | 5 GB, 25 sends/day |
On the invoice, Mango is cheaper from three people up. But look at the last column: on the cheapest plan that fits, each person gets less than a fifth of the storage and a handful of sends per day.
The same comparison with equal storage
Give every person 10 GB, the same as MailAfiniti Starter, and pick the Mango plan whose shared pool covers it:
| Team size | Storage needed | MailAfiniti Starter | Mango plan that fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 person | 10 GB | $18 | $60 Small Business (30 GB) |
| 3 people | 30 GB | $54 | $60 Small Business (30 GB) |
| 5 people | 50 GB | $90 | $174 Mini Tycoon (100 GB) |
| 10 people | 100 GB | $180 | $174 Mini Tycoon (100 GB) |
At equal storage, MailAfiniti costs the same or less up to about ten people. Past 100 GB, Mango has no larger self-serve plan, so you'd need to ask them.
It comes down to your team's usage. If most people keep under a gigabyte and send a few emails a day, Mango's shared plans will cost less. If people send dozens of emails daily, or keep years of history, compare against the second table.
MailAfiniti
Your own domain email, set up in minutes
We handle all the technical bits. You just pick your domain and go.
When to pick Mango Mail vs MailAfiniti
Pick Mango Mail if:
- You're one person, or a team whose mailboxes are mostly quiet
- You run several businesses or domains and want them under one cheap subscription
- You need lots of role addresses that receive mail but rarely send
- You're comfortable doing your own migration and DNS setup
Pick MailAfiniti if:
- Your team sends email all day, and a shared daily cap would get in the way
- Each person keeps years of mail and needs their own storage
- You want us to move your existing mail for you (free on Professional and Enterprise)
- You want the SPF, DKIM and DMARC records generated for you, with a person to help when DNS gets confusing
How to Move from Mango Mail to MailAfiniti
Mango supports standard IMAP (its setup guide lists the server settings), so moving works the same as from any other host:
- Start a MailAfiniti trial and add your domain. We generate the DNS records for you to paste into your registrar.
- Create a mailbox for each person.
- Copy the mail across over IMAP. On Professional and Enterprise, we do this step for you.
- Switch your MX records to MailAfiniti once the copy is done. New mail starts arriving within minutes to a few hours, depending on your DNS settings.
- Point Outlook, Apple Mail or phones at MailAfiniti's IMAP and SMTP settings.
The email migration guide covers each step in detail.
Frequently asked questions
Is Mango Mail cheaper than MailAfiniti?
For one person they cost the same: $18 a year. From three people up, Mango's invoice is lower because it charges per account, not per mailbox. But Mango's storage and daily sending limits are shared, so each person gets less as the team grows. With 10 GB per person on both, MailAfiniti costs the same or less up to about ten people.
What are Mango Mail's sending limits?
Mango's plan details list 50 outgoing emails per day on Startup, 100 on Small Business and 500 on Mini Tycoon. These limits apply to the whole account, not to each mailbox. Incoming mail is also capped per day: 200, 1,000 and 3,000.
Does Mango Mail really have unlimited mailboxes?
Yes. Every Mango plan includes unlimited addresses and unlimited domains. The limits are on total storage and daily mail volume across the account, rather than on how many mailboxes you create.
Is Mango Mail good for a small business?
It's a good fit for one-person businesses and teams with quiet mailboxes, especially if you run several domains. Teams that send a lot of email should check the daily sending cap first: on Startup, 50 outgoing emails a day is shared by everyone on the account.
What is a good Mango Mail alternative?
If a shared account cap is the problem, look for a host that gives each mailbox its own storage. MailAfiniti charges $18 per mailbox per year with 10 GB each, so a three-person team pays $54 a year for 30 GB, close to Mango's $60 Small Business plan for the same total storage, without one inbox crowding the others.
Can I move from Mango Mail to MailAfiniti without losing email?
Yes. Mango supports IMAP, so every folder and message can be copied across before you switch MX records. Migration is free and done for you on MailAfiniti's Professional and Enterprise plans.
The Bottom Line
Mango Mail is one of the cheapest ways to get email on your own domain, and for a solo founder or a set of quiet role addresses it's a fair deal. Its limits are on the account rather than the mailbox, which is fine until your team starts sharing them.
If your team sends all day or keeps years of mail, per-mailbox pricing gives each person their own 10 GB for about the same money at small team sizes. MailAfiniti starts at $1.50 per mailbox per month billed annually.
Start your free 14-day trial, no credit card required
Related reading
- Cheap Business Email Hosting: budget-tier comparison
- MailAfiniti vs TrekMail: the other flat-rate option compared
- Email Migration Guide: how to switch providers without losing mail
MailAfiniti
Stop using Gmail for your business
From $1.50/mo. Your domain, your email, your reputation. Up and running today.
No credit card required to start.